When common sense gets cancer.
Last Sunday evening after church, the young-married group had a chili supper to raise money for a retreat. Towards the end of the evening, a fellow who I'll refer to as MP sat down and struck up a conversation with me in regard to nutrition and health. He and I share a common interest in this area, but not a common view. I take a very simple approach to good health; eat right, exercise, etc. God gave us pretty much all that we need to stay healthy, all we need to do is make use of it and not pervert something healthy into something unhealthy. MP (whom I do have a great deal of respect for) believes that homoeopathy and naturopathy are the roads good health and longevity.
The conversation began with MP telling me about a new Natruopath (practicioner of naturopathy) that he visits in lieu of a physician. He said that this particular provider has a method of looking at a blood sample under a microscope and diagnosing any and all ailments by visually inspecting your blood cells. He went on to say that this provider let him know that his cells were nearly problem free, EXCEPT that the red cells were binding together a bit more than they should (never mind the fact that the blood was on a microscope slide, exposed to air). More on that whole "binding-red-cell" malady later. He then inspected MP's wife's blood. "Without any prompting" he told me, "he said, 'do you have back problems'". In amazement, MP and his wife said that she did indeed have neck problems (close enough). I replied that this seemed to be a very similar approach to what is used by psychics. I then engaged him in a pointed conversation that went something like this;
Me: "So what is the connection, or the cause if you will, in which a sore back, or ankle, or whatever, can change the shape of your blood cells?"
MP: "Well, he can tell by looking at the shape of the cells, and the cell counts."
Me: "I understand that this is his claim, but does he or anyone who makes this claim have a valid explanation as to how these maladies effect cell shape?"
MP: "Well, they can diagnose cancer by looking at your blood."
Me: "That's because there is a real and demonstrable link between cancer and your cell counts. The connection has been proven. Just as it has with types of anemia, etc. Has such medical proof been provided for these other forms of blood diagnostics."
The conversation shifted gears at that point to stomach enzymes, and the fact that after 30 we don't produce enough of our own to digest food. This is the cause of the rampant acid-reflux that so many suffer with, he told me. It seems that both of his daughters-in-law and even his wife suffer from this. The same naturopath that diagnoses sore joints and muscles by observing cell shape sells a supplement called DigestMore that fixes this very problem. Additionally, this lack of proper digestion was what had been causing MP's red cells to "bind" according to his Naturopath. I asked what was in these "completely natural pills" and MP told me that they are "vegetable enzymes". I'm not sure exactly what that means, but my next logical question was "Why not just eat more vegetables". "Oh, that's almost all we eat" he said. "Then what am I missing" I asked. Back to the beginning we went, with the whole "after 30" thing.
I basically told him in the end that I really thought that this was all quackery, but that I certainly agreed with him that proper diet and exercise was imperative, even a moral requirement and that the lack thereof is epidemic in our society and more so our church. He agreed. I went on to make the comment that I, as a relatively healthy person who tries hard to take care of myself am tired of subsidizing others poor health and nutrition habits via high insurance premiums. That was a trigger...he informed me that he had cancelled his insurance long ago, as he trusted God to keep him healthy and to heal him when he does get ill. Okay, fair enough. "Doctors want to keep us sick" he told me. Not so fair. In fact, blatantly false I would maintain. I told him that it seemed to me that he was putting more trust in magic pills and witch-doctors than in God and the very things he created for us to consume for our good.
So, in the end, we agree to disagree...mostly. I am glad that he works hard to be healthy, but the idea that you have to spend money on DigestMore and barley juice in order to be healthy is, well, not healthy. It doesn't cost "extra" to be healthy. Actually, it's usually cheaper to buy wholesome foods at the grocery as most people don't want them so the whole supply and demand effect works to your advantage. Getting off the couch and walking/running/doing jumping jacks doesn't cost a dime. God gave us skepticism for a reason. While we cannot let it get out of hand, it is important to always have a healthy skepticism as it serves to preserve us physically, emotionally and (in this case) financially. Skepticism and common sense would seem to serve as a system of checks and balances for one another. If one falls short, the other should pick up the slack. If we willfully set one aside then we are destined for disappointment. In the end, we live in a fallen and acursed world. Everyone gets sick. Everyone dies. If you are deathly ill and God heals you then rejoice, but understand that the inevitable has only been delayed and assume that it is because God has something remaining for you to accomplish. While death, sin and sickness used to hold us hostage, it is Christ's death on the cross that provided the ultimate healing in that it stripped sickness and death of their power.



